All workers have the right to a safe and healthful workplace and to a fair wage that offers them an opportunity to realize the American dream. Over the past century, we’ve tried to breathe life into that value by enacting hundreds of labor laws and establishing numerous federal agencies to implement and enforce them, like the Department of Labor (DOL), the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), and the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB), among others. States also play a major role in protecting workers’ rights by administering state-level programs that carry out the minimum federal requirements and any supplemental state protections.
But the American workplace has changed dramatically since many of our labor laws were last updated, and so have the inherent hazards for workers. New, bigger, more powerful equipment has come online. New chemicals and other toxic substances have come into routine use. New production and construction methods have been introduced. At the same time, more and more employers rely on “contingent” workers instead of permanent employees to perform jobs at all levels. Employers are also fighting grassroots efforts to raise the minimum wage, denying sick leave and family medical leave, misclassifying workers to avoid overtime pay, and retaliating against workers who report wrongdoing.
More than 30,000 workers have died as a result of on-the-job injuries since 2009, many because their employers failed to follow safety procedures -- violations for which OSHA imposed fines. But a report from CPR finds that OSHA is routinely discounting those fines, greatly diminishing any deterrent value.
In its early years, OSHA made great progress reducing workplace injuries and deaths. But the war on regulation triggered a steady decline in OSHA’s ambition and effectiveness, and progress has nearly stopped.
Workers face powerful disincentives to raise concerns about health and safety in the workplace. All states have some form of whistleblower protection law, though they vary widely in their scope and implementation, and in the actual safeguards they provide.
CPR's Winning Safer Workplaces manual for state and local advocates highlights successful campaigns to adopt local workplace safety standards, and offers innovative proposals to help advocates make headway despite intense opposition from big-moneyed, anti-regulatory interests.
Our labor laws have not kept pace with these new and emerging technological and economic developments. At the federal level, many agencies have been starved of the resources they need to keep up with regulatory challenges and burdened with analytical requirements by adverse court decisions and congressional action. The result is that new safety standards can take a decade or more to implement, and enforcement of existing standards is sporadic at best. Thus, many workers and advocates are beginning to look at states and localities to strengthen protections. Achieving meaningful, long-lasting reform will require improvements to laws and regulations at the federal, state, and local level. Working with government officials, workers and advocates must find creative and focused responses to existing and new challenges in the workplace.
CPR’s Member Scholars and policy analysts have conducted extensive research and analyses that provide numerous legal and policy recommendations that can be pursued by government decision-makers and allied organizations. Please read more about securing workers’ economic rights, reforming federal labor laws and policies, and winning safer workplaces by advocating for strong worker protections at the state and local level.
Crimes Against Workers Database
Worker deaths or injuries resulting from conditions that violate workplace safety laws are all too common. Often, rather than treating these violations of the law as subjects for criminal investigation, prosecutors simply defer to OSHA or comparable state agencies, thus significantly reducing the scope of possible penalties. As a result, many workplace injuries or deaths resulting from illegal conditions are punished with fines, and light fines at that, letting violators off too easily and eliminating the deterrent effect that might prevent future incidents. Some prosecutors have recognized the need to treat such incidents as the crimes they are, prosecuting employers who've broken the law. CPR's first-of-its-kind Crimes Against Workers database catalogs state criminal cases and grassroots advocacy campaigns against employers responsible for workers being killed, maimed, or serious endangered on the job. It provides a one-stop shop for finding case files, media clips, and advocacy resources related to state criminal enforcement against companies and individuals in cases of serious worker injuries and deaths.
Letter on Ag Bill Exemption re Hazardous Chemicals. Read a joint letter to House and Senate Agriculture Committee Chairs and Ranking Members from Tom McGarity, Sid Shapiro, and Rena Steinzor opposing section of the House Farm Bill (H.R. 2) that would codify exemption of high-risk retail facilities that sell hazardous chemicals to commercial end users from OSHA’s Process Safety Management standard, September 24, 2018.
Letters to Maryland Gubernatorial Candidates re Worker Safety. Read letters from CPR's Rena Steinzor and Katie Tracy to Maryland gubernatorial candidates Larry Hogan and Ben Jealous calling for a strengthened Maryland Occupational Safety and Health division, September 21, 2018.
Maryland Testimony. Read Katherine Tracy and Matthew Shudtz' testimony (submitted) to Maryland General Assembly House Standing Committee on Appropriations, Subcommittee on Education & Economic Development on appropriations for the Maryland Occupational Safety and Health division of the Department of Licensing, Labor, and Regulation, February 8, 2018. MOSH’s limited budget hampers its ability to ensure the health and safety of Maryland workers.
Texas City Refinery Blast Anniversary. Read Rena Steinzor's op-ed in the Houston Chronicle, March 20, 2015, on lessons -- learned and otherwise -- from the BP Texas City oil refinery explosion in 2005.
Winning Safer Workplaces. Mindful that federal OSHA has been rendered slow to respond and comparatively toothless, CPR Member Scholars collaborated in 2014 on Winning Safer Workplaces: A Manual for State and Local Policy Reformto provide state and local advocates a tool to use to accomplish reforms that address the changing nature of work in the United States.