On Tuesday, March 31, House Energy and Commerce Committee Chairman Henry Waxman (D-CA) and Rep. Edward Markey (D-MA) released a “discussion draft” of the American Clean Energy and Security Act of 2009 – a climate change bill that will serve as the starting point for long-delayed congressional action on the world’s most pressing environmental program. CPRBlog asked several Center for Progressive Reform Member Scholars to examine different aspects of the 648-page Waxman-Markey bill. This entry, by Nina Mendelson, looks at what the bill would do to reassert the right of citizens to bring suit – either against polluters or against recalcitrant regulators – to enforce the law’s provisions.
By setting solid targets for reducing global warming in a cap-and-trade system and including a host of other helpful provisions, the Waxman-Markey bill is a terrific first contribution to this Congress’s debate on climate change. A less obvious but still extremely positive aspect of the bill is its approach to citizen enforcement of the laws. In addition to government enforcement provisions, the bill includes strong citizen suit provisions. It reaffirms the importance of citizen enforcement of the environmental laws against both potential violators and agencies that have the responsibility to implement the regime. Citizens have traditionally had this enforcement power under the environmental laws, but it has recently been threatened by a series of judicial decisions. The Waxman-Markey bill responds to these judicial decisions and strives to ensure the vitality of citizen suits.
Environmental statutes traditionally provide for citizen enforcement suits as a critical supplement to governmental enforcement, especially in a world of limited budgets. Citizens can also use these suits to hold government accountable for carrying out statutory obligations, and citizen suits can enable individuals to be proactive in protecting their environment. The possibility of facing such suits has prompted many companies to take compliance obligations more seriously and government agencies to move faster on implementing environmental programs.
Supreme Court decisions have, however, created uncertainty regarding when and which citizens can bring such suits to protect the environment, particularly in the climate change setting. With respect to climate change, the Supreme Court has held that a litigant must show it has suffered a “concrete and particularized injury that is either actual or imminent, that the injury is fairly traceable to the defendant, and that it is likely that a favorable decision will redress that injury.” In its 2007 decision in Massachusetts v. EPA, the Court acknowledged that the harms associated with climate change are “serious and well recognized,” and it did find that Massachusetts had standing, applying a special rule for States. However, the Court has not squarely ruled that an individual or other non-state entity’s injury from climate change can be sufficiently “particularized” to create standing to sue. This is a concern, because although many individuals may suffer from climate change, a particular violation of a climate change regime may be small and the harm from climate change can be widespread. Although the Supreme Court has acknowledged that even small actions, or small failures to act, can worsen the harm from climate change, so that the State of Massachusetts had standing to challenge EPA’s failure to regulate greenhouse gases, the Court has not confirmed that even small actions should be seen as contributing to “actual” and “imminent” individual losses from climate change.
Some members of the Court have suggested, however, that Congress has the power to “define injuries and articulate chains of causation that will give rise to a case or controversy where none existed before,” and implied that the judiciary will respect such judgments. The Waxman-Markey bill takes up this invitation. The bill includes legislative findings that very small incremental increases in greenhouse gas emissions can worsen climate change and increase the risk of injury to individuals, as well as language suggesting that individuals suffering such small injuries can bring citizen suits, even if the injuries are widely shared. The bill also includes a novel provision authorizing limited compensation of a citizen for the increased risk of injury from global warming – in short, creating a new claim that a citizen could assert to recover damages from a violation of the statute. The worthy goal here is to reaffirm the importance of citizen enforcement and attempt to solidify the ground on which such suits stand.
Nina Mendelson, CPR Member Scholar; Professor of Law, University of Michigan Law School. Bio.
| 1 What a terrific and informative piece. I actually provided a link to it on my own blog. Keep up the good work! http://tinyurl.com/c3f4hg -- Andy Hoffman |
| 2 Wow i can say that this is another great article as expected of this blog.Bookmarked this site.. -- sajid arzoo |
| 3 It is so interesting. I want to know some other information about this site. So please give me this news quickly. I always will be aware of you.
http://www.gw2gw2.com/gold.html
-- Brooke Brooke |
| 4 Just wanted to drop a comment and say I am new to your blog and really like what I am reading. Thanks for the great content. Look forward to coming back for more...... -- love quotes for your boyfriend love quotes for your boyfriend |
| 5 I am sure that more informative posts like this are coming soon. -- lil wayne quotes and sayings lil wayne quotes and sayings |
| 6 Your blog is awesome! It is a pleasure to read it. I will definitely come back! Cheers -- paracord survival bracelets |
| 7 Visita http://www.tupecado.com y conocer?s las putas Madrid que har?n todo para ti. Las putas Madrid que buscas est?n en la gu?a preferida de Madrid -- Placas solares Sevilla saniya |
| 8 This is really interesting, I like it. -- grupna kupovina |
| 9 Heya i am for the first time here. I found this board and I find It truly useful & it helped me out a lot. I hope to give something back and help others like you helped me. -- saniyamirja saniya |
| 10 Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is extremely helpful for me.
http://www.cleaningforareason.com.au/ -- aashton noble |
| 11 I needed to thank you for this excellent information!! -- Slameto Tohak |
| 12 Peel tingly the epigastralgia on the hourglass pack and test the on your tongue.
[url=http://psychologycollegefinder.org/degrees/social-work]degree in social work[/url]
-- josef clare |
| 13 Hello. Very cool blog!! Guy.. Excellent.. Amazing.. I will bookmark your blog and take the feeds also... Thanks for one`s marvelous posting! I actually enjoyed reading it. -- Butlins Skegness Holiday |
| 14 Thank you very much best essay writing service for you can share your post,the article content written very well, writes fluent,extremely is worth my study. -- ahmed wasim |
| 15 Very well written post. It will be valuable to everyone who employess it, including myself. Keep doing what you are doing. Yoga Sutras -- Yoga Sutras |
| 16 I’m very impressed with your interesting post. It has astonishing information. I appreciate with your great, but there is a need to little bit improve in your writing skillnews on israel
-- nitin khare |
| 17 It was said that Supreme Court decisions have created uncertainty regarding when and which citizens can bring such suits to protect the environment, particularly in the climate change setting. But, I say that EVERYONE has the right to do such thing because everyone is affected with the climate change, right? This is not, in fact, a problem. We are just the ones creating our own problems, frankly speaking.
Jeremy -- Jeremy Roy |
| 18 It reaffirms the importance of citizen enforcement of the environmental laws against both potential violators and agencies that have the responsibility to implement the regime. nursing profession -- ahmed wasim |
| 19 Is it true that when we most need advice we are least willing to listen to it? Or is good advice always welcome? Plan your response, and then write an essay.
florida asbestos attorney -- ynah hany |
| 20 hanukkah traditions
Thanks for sharing the information. I found the information very helpful. That's a awesome article you posted. I will come back to read some more -- Nitin khare |
| 21 All of a sudden, everybody is now concerned about global warming and sudden climate change! I just hope we are not too late! So, how's the bill going since it's almost around four years now since this article was written? -- Alexis Gagnon |
| 22 All of a sudden, everybody is now concerned about global warming and sudden climate change! I just hope we are not too late! So, how's the bill going since it's almost around four years now since this article was written? Alexis Gagnon -- Alexis Gagnon |
| 23 I completely agree with the previous comment. Thank you for such an interesting and comprehensive answer. international logistics company -- Doris Greys |
| 24 Dissertation writing services by “Quality Assignment” will surely satisfy you, now get the custom dissertation services within your range.
ac repair chicago -- wasim ahmed |
| 25 I just love CPRblog and I love they way talk about all th eissues. feel free to check my site about < ahref="http://casino.imcredo.com/services/seo/">casino seo that helps sites to promote on the internet. -- sumty mahala |
| 26 I just love CPRblog and I love they way talk about all th eissues. feel free to check my site about < ahref="http://casino.imcredo.com/services/seo/">casino seo that helps sites to promote on the internet. -- sumty mahala |
| 27 I just love CPRblog and I love they way talk about all th eissues. feel free to check my site about casino seo that helps sites to promote on the internet.
-- sumty mahala -- sumty mahala |
| 28 we dicided we needed to buy a good project planning software for our company to keep track of the tasks and the projects. -- EasyProjects.net sfhh |
| 29 Super professional help of the Microwave Moisture Meter -- srg sdg |
| 30 We decided to move and with a little help of San Benito Real Estate we were pleased with their service. -- Homepelf dd |
| 31 Hey that was great to read. Thanks for the great post .Loved every part of it. Lipozene Reviews -- Lipozene Reviews Lipozene Reviews |
| 32 I highly recommend to buy only rattan furniture because its the most safe furniture you can find today. -- RATTANUSA dfgdfg |
| 33 We played all night long in the Online Slots and it was so much fun with the slots, omg. -- WKC degfd |
| 34 We decided to purchase good software - Online Payment Gateway - to keep track of the time and work that needs to be done. -- ECOM CHARGE |
| 35 It has great details and yet it is easy to understand.That's what i was looking for. I will definitely share it with others.Thanks for sharing.
james bond skyfall barbour jacket
-- Kristina Marshall |
| 36 This is a really good post. Must admit that you are amongst the best bloggers I have read. Thanks for posting this informative article.I really enjoyed when i read this here a lots of use information and many topics to read and share. phuket detox -- kapil dev |
| 37 Well this is very extraordinary indeed. I adore to read a little about this meticulous topic. Great Article. Its in fact very informatics blog, I just would like to say that I found this precious blog with the help of Google. and I hope that you will be keep posting such type of Articles.
stryker hip lawsuit -- ynah hany |
